The Straight Dope: Could the floating islands of "Life of Pi" really exist?

The Straight Dope - Fighting Ignorance Since 1973
Learn about Cecil Adams, the world's smartest human. Read a random Straight
Dope column. Ask Cecil a question.
Home Message Boards Ask the Master Who is Cecil Adams? Archive


Nothing in their lives unbecame them like the leaving it. (NSFW)
Submitted by JoseB (NOTE: Dark humor/potentially inappropriate/unsettling.)
Best of the Straight Dope Message Board
Send your nominations for Threadspotting and Weird Earl’s to Do it today!
It's a DopeFest outing summer style, and you're invited.
Submitted by Musicat
This ordnance is part of a complete breakfast.
Submitted by G. Mills
Goooooooooooooooo team!
Submitted by Musicat
It's a bird! It's a plane! It's...a dead cat!
Submitted by Musicat, who also wrote the tag, thanks!
Visit the Straight Dope Message Board

Search The Straight Dope

** Could the floating islands of "Life of Pi" really exist? **

June 1, 2007

Dear Cecil:

In /Life of Pi/, Yann Martel describes a floating island of vegetation with
its own ecosystem that could be boarded and had animals living on it out in
the middle of the ocean. It seems far-fetched, but does anything like this

— Tim M., UK

Not to deprecate the novelist's art, Tim, but /Life of Pi/ also speaks of
carnivorous islands whose trees bear fruit containing human teeth. Mini
terrestrial ecosystems adrift in midocean are likewise too cool to be real.
However, floating islands of more modest scope do exist, typically in
freshwater where there's less wave and tidal action.

One example is the peat batteries of the Okefenokee Swamp in Georgia and
Florida. These form when large masses of peat lying on the floor of the
swamp accumulate enough methane and


are there islands like in life of pi

© 2005-2021